Evidence for the Shiite Point of View
The Shia have a great deal of evidence to support their point of view, so much so that the great scholar al-.ill: composed a book named al-alfayn ‘the two thousand’ in which he mentioned two thousand proofs for the Shiite point of view many of which are sourced from Sunnite books and collections of traditions. In what follows, a few of these evidences will be mentioned:
The Evidence for the Successorship of Ali
The Messenger of Allah Muhammad ibn Abdullah (S) alluded to and indicated, stated and reiterated time and again about the successorship of Ali ibn Abi Talib (a.s.). For example:
1. The Warning of his close family
This occasion known as the day of warning (yawm al-indhar) has been documented by many top Sunnite scholars such as Ibn Ishaq, Ibn Jarir, Ibn Abi .atim, al-Tabari and others.
This happened at the beginning of the Prophet’s mission, before Islam appeared openly in Mecca after Allah had revealed to the Prophet (S) the words: “And warn thy close family”
The Messenger of Allah (S) invited his relatives to the house of his uncle Abi Talib (a.s.) and there were forty men there more or less, including his uncles Abi Talib, Hamza, al-Abbas, and Abu Lahab. At the end of the discussions the Prophet said to them: ‘O sons of Abd al-Muttalib, I swear by Allah that I do not know of a young man of the Arabs who has brought his people something better than that which I bring you - I bring you the best of this world and the next. Allah has ordered me to invite you to this [Islam], so which of you will aid me in this affair of mine so that he will be my brother and my trustee and my successor amongst you?’
All were silent except for Ali (a.s.) who was the youngest of them. He stood up and said: ‘O Prophet of Allah, I will be your aid in this affair.’ Then the Messenger of Allah (S) put his hand on Ali’s shoulder and said: ‘This is my brother and my trustee (wasiy) and my successor (khalifa) amongst you so hear him and obey him.’
2. The Day of Ghadir
The tradition of Ghadir has been related by one hundred and twenty of the companions of the Messenger of Allah (S) and eighty-four of the generation after them (al-tabiun). The number of prominent traditionists who narrated this tradition exceeds three hundred and sixty.
.
Those who have written about this tradition in books from both the Sunni and Shia schools number more than 166 people. In brief, when the Messenger of Allah Muhammad (S) returned from the final ‘farewell’ .ajj pilgrimage he reached a location named ‘Ghadir Khumm’. There he halted the people and mounted a pulpit in the noonday heat and delivered a long sermon in front of more than one hundred thousand people. During this speech he took hold of the hand of Ali (a.s.) and said: ‘O people, Allah is my master (mawla) and I am the master of the believers and I have more authority over them than they do over their own selves. So whoever I am the master of then this man - Ali - is his master. O Allah, be allied with who is allied with him and the enemy of he who is his enemy. I will surely ask you, when we meet again [in the afterlife] about the two weighty matters (al-thaqalayn) and how you act towards them after I am gone - the greater weighty thing is the Quran, the book of Almighty Allah. It is a heavenly course (sabab) one end of which is in the hand of Allah and the other end is in your hands so hold firmly on to it and go not astray and do not take any substitute for it. And [secondly] my family, the people of my house, for the Subtle and All-Aware [Allah] has informed me that they will never perish until they meet me at the well of Paradise.’
Imam Ahmad mentions in his musnad: ‘that the Prophet (S) took the hand of Ali (a.s.) and said to those present: ‘Do you not know that I have more authority over the believers than they do over their own selves?’ They said: ‘Indeed we do.’ He said: ‘Do you not know that I have more authority over every believer than he does over his own self?’ They said: ‘Indeed we do.’ The he said: ‘Whoever I am his master (mawla: lit. place of authority) then Ali is his master. O Allah, be allied to his allies and be an enemy to his enemies.’ The narrator continues: ‘Then Umar went to him afterwards and said to him: ‘Congratulations O son of Abi Talib, you have now become the master of every believing man and woman!’
In his book al-wilaya, al-Tabari relates that after this the Messenger of Allah (S) ordered that his companions greet Ali in acknowledgement of him as commander of the believers. Hence, the companions used to come to him and say to him ‘Peace be upon you O Commander of the Faithful ()!’
In answer to those who say that the Prophet (S) did not nominate a successor we would say that this is not sensible or logical especially as the Prophet was the most intelligent and sensible of people. He would not ever leave Medina even for a few days without nominating someone to lead the community in his place so when it came to his death it is not possible that he should leave his community rudderless.
3. The tradition of the ‘station’
The tradition of the ‘station’ (manzilah), which has been mentioned by Imams Ahmad and al-Nasai and others, was when the Messenger of Allah (S) said to Ali (a.s.): ‘Will you not be content for your station to me to be as that of Aaron to Moses except that there is no prophet to come after me?’
‘I cannot go unless you are my successor (khalifa).’
And there are great many other traditions and evidences to this effect.
4. Successorship of other Imams from Prophet’s family
The Messenger of Allah (S) spoke, by the authority of Allah, about the successorship of the Imams after him saying: ‘There will be twelve successors after me.’
This has been narrated by Abu Dawud, Muslim, Ahmad ibn .anbal, and others.
The Prophet (S) nominated them and mentioned their names on many occasions as is mentioned in the book yanabi almawadda
for example related from the Messenger of Allah (S) in a tradition where someone asked him about the awsiya’ (trustees) those who would execute his will after him. The person asked him, ainform me of your was
i.” The prophet said: ‘My executor is Ali ibn Abi Talib, and after him my two grandsons Hasan and Husayn followed by nine Imams from the line of Husayn.’ The man said: ‘O Muhammad, name them!’ He said: ‘When Husayn has gone there will be his son Ali; when Ali has gone there will be his son Muhammad; when Muhammad has gone there will be his son Jafar; when Jafar has gone there will be his son Musa; when Musa has gone there will be his son Ali; when Ali has gone there will be his son Muhammad; when Muhammad has gone there will be his son Ali; when Ali has gone there will be his son Hasan; when Hasan has gone there will be his son Muhammad - the Mahdi - the Guided - the Hujjah - Proof of Allah.’
5. The tradition of the two weighty things
The Messenger of Allah (S) left two weighty things (al-thaqalayn) in his will - the Quran and his family, and he ordered the Muslims to follow these two in a well known tradition which has been recorded by both Sunni and Shia schools. The Prophet (S) said: ‘I am leaving with you the two weighty things - the book of Allah and my family the people of my house (Ahl al-Bayt). As long as you adhere to these two you will never ever go astray after me.’
In another tradition he said: ‘I am leaving with you two successors (khalifatayn) - the book of Allah which is a rope extending between heaven and earth, and my family the people of my house (Ahl al-Bayt). They will never separate until they join me at the well of Paradise.’
He also said: ‘I am leaving with you two successors - the book of Allah and the people of my house. These two will never separate until they both join me at the well of Paradise.’
He also said: ‘I am leaving behind me two things so you will never go astray - the book of Allah and my lineage. They will never separate until they join me at the well of Paradise.’
He also said: ‘I shall shortly die and I have left with you the two weighty things - the book of Allah and the people of my house. uou will never go astray with these two things.’