DebateWith
A Jurist
AFaqih
(jurist) happened to come to Baghdad fromKhorasan
andHaroon
Rashid invited him to his court. When he arrived,Haroon
accorded him everyhonour
and made him sit next to him. By chanceBahlool
also appeared in the court andHaroon
also
accorded him due respect and made him sit nearby.
Thejurist on seeing the crazy outlook ofBahlool
remarked that it was rather surprising for the Caliph to welcome such people hear
him.WhenBahlool
overheard thisrernark
, he, retorted by telling the jurist not to be puffed up with his little and imperfect knowledge.
He further claimed that he was prepared to debate with him and prove his ignorance. The jurist reacted to this by saying that what could he talk to an insane person.And
Bahlool
responded by saying:
" I
may confess my insanity but you do not accept the challenge to your own ignorance and imperfect knowledge"
On hearing this hot, exchange,Haroon
tried to calmBahlool
but he would not.Again
he challenged the jurist to enter a polemic conversation with him if at all he was confident of his knowledge.Haroon
said to the jurist:
"What is the objection, why not put some questions toBahlool
?" To this, the jurist responded by saying: "I am willing to doso on
condition that if he failed to answer satisfactorily, he should pay a thousand dinars in gold coins. Likewise he would pay similar amount if he failed."
Bahlool
responded that from the worldlytreasure
he had nothing but should he be defeated, he was willing to enter into the slavery of the jurist. The jurist then put forward this question:
"Supposing a woman was sitting in a house with her husband.
And
a man was occupied in prayers and another person was in the state of fasting. During thatperiod
another man entered that house, the marriage of wife and husband became mutually null and void, whilst the prayer of the one who was praying and the fasting of the one who fasted also became unacceptable. Who was the person who entered the house?"
In reply to the above question,Bahlool
promptly answered by explaining that the person who entered that house was the previous husband of that woman. He had gone on a journey and had not returned for quite some time. The woman was informed that he had died, so after securing the consent ofHakime
Sheria
(Executer of Islamic Laws) she married again with the man with whom, she was sitting.
Besides
she had arranged with those other two men on behalf of the husband who was reckoned to be dead.
Now as soon as her first husband who was alive entered thehouse ,
the first marriage revived and the second marriage became automatically null and void. And that prayer and fasting on hisbehalf also
became unnecessary, since prayer and fast on behalf of one who is alive is not acceptable in the IslamicSharia
Haroon
and his courtiers were much impressed by this logic answer.Bahlool
then took his turn and posed the following question to the jurist:
"Supposing one bowl is full of sugar syrup andwhile
another one with vinegar.
Iffor the purpose of
preparing 'Sikanjabin
' (a kind of vinegar syrup), we put them in third bowl and we find a small rat in it. How can we determine whether that rat originally was in the bowl of vinegar or in that of thesupar
syrup?" To this question put forward byBahlooi
, the jurist had no answer to give.Haroon
noticing his.
silence
, called for the answer fromBahlool
himself andBahlool
answered:
"We should first remove the dead rat from the syrup, wash it withwater
and thence tear open its body to see what was there in its tummy. If we find vinegar, we can conclude that the rat had got into the bowl of vinegar. If however, we find sugar syrup in its tummy, we conclude that it was originally in the bowl of syrup."
On hearing this answer totne
question, all those present in the court were awe struck with the remarkable intelligence ofBahlool
.
Finally
the jurist had to part with the agreed sum of a thousand dinars of gold toBahlool
who instead of pocketing them himself, distributed among the poor. This polemic betweenBahlool
and the jurist denotes the deep knowledge he had in Islamic jurisprudence. This madehtm
famous to be held in high esteem despite his insanely ways of living.
The following sayings of the Prophet are herewith worth noting: "He whose knowledge is higher is considered more in value than others" "A slip by a learned becomes widely publicized whereas that of an ignorant gets covered up under his ignorance".
"The happiness of this world and the nextHas
in learning and the evil of this world .and the next in ignorance"