A Critical Assessment of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim

This book is corrected and edited by Al-Hassanain (p) Institue for Islamic Heritage and Thought

Author: Ayatullah Sayyid Ali Husaini Milani
Translator: Sayyid Abur Rauf Afzali
Publisher: www.shiamawaddatbooks.com
Category:

Book library ›

Al Hadith and Its Sciences ›

Various Books

visits: 6827
Download: 4006

Forward
A critical assessment of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim
Part One: A Critical Assessment of Sahih Bukhari
Chapter One
Bukhari as a Narrator
Abu Zar’ah and Abu Hatam on Bukhari
A glance at the biography of Abu Zar’ah Razi
A glance at biography of Abu Hatam Razi
Zuhli and his criticism of Bukhari
A glance at Duhli’s life
Bukhari and his deviation from the path of Ahl al-Bayt
Ibn Dihya’s opinion
A glance at Ibn Dihya’s life
Bukhari and Ghadir tradition
Major Sunni scholars and Ghadir tradition
Ibn JAzer and Ghadir tradition
Bukhari and his skepticism about Imam Sadiq’s traditions
Sunni scholars and issue of loving Prophet’s progeny
Are they truthful in making this claim?
Qattan and his criticism of Imam Sadiq (a.s)
Who is Mujalid bin Sa’eed?
Dahabi and Imam Sadiq (a.s)
Who is Qattan?
Incredible claims
The story of Ibn Madini’s al-Ilal
Chapter Two
Baseless Traditions in Sahih Bukhari
The tradition of ‘[Prophet’s] proposing to 'Aisha
The tradition of ‘intercession of Ibrahim for Azer’
Fakhr Razi’s opinion
Ibn Hajar Asqalani and justification of this tradition
Falsity of Ibn Hajar's view
The tradition of Prophet's ‘praying on the corpse of Ibn Abu Sulul’
Why this tradition was fabricated?
The tradition of ‘three lies told by Prophet Ibrahim’
Fakhr Razi rejects this tradition
The tradition of ‘a prophet setting ant’s nest on fire’
Fakhr Razi rejects this tradition
The tradition of ‘eating forbidden meat’
Distortion in a fabricated tradition
Justification of meaning of tradition
Some Sunni scholars accept this false tradition
Others are after solution
An evacuation of this solution
The tradition ‘Prophets do not leave behind inheritance’
The tradition of ‘Ali’s quarrel with Prophet over nightprayer’
A glance at Imam Ali’s excellences
Fabricated tradition and the objection of fatalism
Falsity of fatalism from the viewpoint of Ibn Taymiyya
Ibn Taymiyya and appealing to a fabricated tradition
The tradition of Ali's ‘proposing to Abu Jahl’s daughter’
The tradition of 'the cause of the revelation of Quranic verse'
The tradition that allows taking wage for reciting from the Holy Quran
The tradition of 'asking for rain' narrated by Asbat
The tradition 'traditions will increase after me'
The tradition that prohibits (playing) musical instruments
The tradition 'a believing adulterer does not in fact commit adultery'
Three persons take Prophet to Mi'araj
Monkey stoned to death for fornication
Bukhari and three other fabricated traditions
Great Sunni leaders and these fabricated traditions
A critique of Asqalani's point of view
The Tradition Masruq Narrates from Um Ruman
Great memorizers and this fabricated tradition
A glance at the life account of some the [said] memorizers
An account of the life of 'Alai, a memorizer
Ibn Sikkin and the said fabricated tradition
An evaluation of the opinion of author of al-Huda
Temporary Marriage forbidden in Khaibar year
Great Sunni scholars and this fake tradition
Ibn Hajar 'Asqalani
Dehlavi
Imam Shaf'ai
Abstract
Part Two: An evaluation of Sahih Muslim
Ibrahim bin Abdullah Sa'adi and Sahih Muslim
Abu Zar'ah Razi and Sahih Muslim
Fabricated traditions in Sahih Bukhari
A fabricated tradition on Abu Talib
Fabricated tradition rejected
Tradition indicative of caliphate of Abu Bakr
Sunni scholars on this fabricated tradition
Umar orders calling to prayer
Two contradictory traditions
First verse revealed to Prophet
Bibliography
Notes

20%

Alhassanain(p) Network for Heritage and Islamic Thought